The Tragedy of King Saul

 

The story of King David is an evergreen favorite among Christians. This year alone, many of the major churches in the Klang Valley had embarked on an in-depth and lengthy study on his life. Yet the first king of the kingdom of Israel was not David but King Saul. Unlike David, Saul is not a favorite topic among churches. This is not surprising for his story is marked primarily by failure. Nevertheless, Saul has an importance in the history of Israel as a nation. As its first monarch, Saul’s kingship marked the transition of Israel from a loose confederation of tribes to a centralized monarchy.

 

Saul and David as depicted by Rembrandt

 

The sad thing about Saul is that he was not always a failure. He was not entirely evil, unlike some of Israel’s later kings. Saul was many-shaded and complex, more like Denethor and Saruman than Sauron, the Dark Lord in The Lord of the Rings. He was more like Robespierre than he was like Hitler. 

Like Saruman and Robespierre, Saul was a man who started well. He was well-intentioned and was respected for his noble bearing. Ultimately, however, like them he was destroyed by fatal character flaws he never overcame. In many ways, his life was like that of a classic Greek tragedy. 

  

The Trajectory of Saul’s Life    

King Saul was the first king of Israel, anointed by the prophet Samuel as described in the Hebrew Bible. He came from the tribe of Benjamin which was descended from the youngest son of the patriarch Jacob and reigned during the late 11th century BCE. Saul was chosen as king during a time when the Israelites desired a monarchy to lead them and defend against external threats, particularly from the Philistines.

When we first encounter Saul, we see him carrying out his responsibility looking for his father’s donkeys. In his first meeting with Samuel, he treated the prophet with the utmost respect. He comes across endearingly as a rustic and somewhat shy young man. Saul never sought to be king. In fact, when the people gathered with Samuel to crown him as king, he was so shy and reluctant to take up kingship that he hid among the baggage (1 Samuel 10:22). 

 

Saul anointed as king (Ref: aish.com, wordpress)

 

The Bible tells us that he had a handsome appearance and noble bearing, yet he struggled with a great sense of insecurity. Looking for his father’s donkeys, he stumbled, as it were, into God’s anointing and a new standing in the kingdom (1 Samuel 9-10). However, the unassuming Saul’s reign began with promise. In his first test, he demonstrated decisive leadership, great generosity, humility, and forgiveness during his rescue of the city of Jabesh Gilead (1 Samuel 11). He was a man we  – and we can easily assume the people of Israel as well – wanted so much to succeed. 

 

In his first test, Saul demonstrated decisive leadership, great generosity, humility, and forgiveness during his rescue of the city of Jabesh Gilead.

 

Saul’s reign began with military successes, including victories over the Ammonites and Philistines. However, over time, his relationship with God and Samuel deteriorated due to disobedience and poor decisions and his rule became increasingly troubled due to disobedience to God’s commands. One notable instance was his presumptuousness in appropriating for himself the act of offering sacrifice, something that was outside his jurisdiction (1 Samuel 13: 9-14). Another was the failure to completely obey God in destroying the Amalekites and their livestock. Instead, Saul spared the king and some of the best livestock (1 Samuel 15). He never could overcome his inward-directed impulses and fear of how his people accepted him.   

A significant aspect of Saul’s story is his complicated relationship with David, who initially served in Saul’s court and became a beloved figure in Israel after defeating the Philistine giant Goliath. Saul grew increasingly jealous of David’s popularity and perceived him as a threat to his throne. This jealousy led to a long pursuit of David, attempting to kill him, even though David was loyal to Saul. He even massacred the priests of Nob who had given shelter to David when David was on the run, an unforgivable sin (1 Samuel 22:6-23). 

 

King Saul throwing a spear at David, as depicted by Gustav Dore.

 

Saul’s reign was marked by periods of psychological distress, described in the Bible as being troubled by an evil spirit. His final years were marked by desperation and further alienation from God. Saul eventually died in battle against the Philistines at Mount Gilboa. Facing defeat, he fell on his own sword to avoid capture. His death also saw the end of his sons, including Jonathan, who was a close friend of David. From a beginning of much promise, Saul ended with a wasted life. 

 

Saul’s reign was marked by periods of psychological distress, described in the Bible as being troubled by an evil spirit. From an oil painting by Ernst Josephson.

 

Lessons from King Saul’s Life

King Saul’s life, as chronicled in the Bible, provides several valuable lessons on leadership, faith, obedience, and character. Here are some key takeaways:

 

Humility and Recognizing One’s Limits

Initially, Saul showed humility, but as his reign progressed, he became more concerned with his power and image. He struggled to accept his limitations and God’s decision to choose David as his successor. This teaches the value of humility and the importance of recognizing that leadership is a responsibility granted by God, not an entitlement.

 

Handling of Success and Power

Whether you view your leadership as a responsibility or entitlement can affect your direction in life. Saul’s early successes made him popular and powerful, but he struggled to handle this success with humility and grace. As Saul became more confident in his own strength and position, he made decisions that reflected pride and arrogance, such as offering sacrifices himself instead of waiting for Samuel. This pride distanced him from God and ultimately led to his downfall. His story shows that success can be dangerous if it leads to arrogance, self-reliance, and a disregard for others.

 

Obedience to God

Saul’s downfall began with his disobedience to God’s commands. Despite being chosen as king, his failure to fully carry out God’s instructions, such as in the case of the Amalekites, led to his rejection by God. This emphasizes the importance of following God’s guidance and commands fully, not partially or selectively.

 

Saul’s biggest concern as king was always on how his people viewed him.

 

The Dangers of Jealousy and Insecurity

Saul’s jealousy of David’s successes and popularity became an obsession that consumed him. This jealousy led to irrational behavior, including attempts on David’s life, and ultimately contributed to his downfall. This teaches the destructive nature of jealousy and insecurity, which can cloud judgment and lead to harmful actions.

 

The Role of Repentance

Saul made several attempts to seek forgiveness after his disobedience, but they often lacked genuine repentance. True repentance involves a sincere acknowledgment of wrongdoing and a commitment to change. Saul’s story shows that repentance should be heartfelt and followed by actions that align with it.

 

The Importance of Listening to Wise Counsel

Saul had Samuel as a prophet and advisor, yet he often ignored Samuel’s counsel. Good leaders should value and heed wise counsel, especially when it challenges their own desires or plans. Saul’s failure to listen to Samuel led to poor decisions and ultimately his downfall.

 

King Saul had a very troubled relationship with his prophet Samuel (Ref: pinimg)

 

Addressing Mental and Emotional Well-being

Saul’s later years were marked by mental and emotional distress, often described as being troubled by an evil spirit. His inability to manage these issues effectively contributed to his erratic behavior. This underscores the importance of addressing mental and emotional health and seeking help when needed.

 

The Weight of Leadership Responsibility and the Importance of Emotional and Wise Support Base 

As the first king of Israel, Saul had a significant responsibility to lead his people according to God’s will. His failures not only affected him but also had a broader impact on the nation. Leaders bear a great responsibility and must lead with integrity, faithfulness, and a commitment to the well-being of those they lead.

Saul also neglected the importance of an emotional and wise support base. He did not listen to Samuel’s wise counsel. He let his emotions govern him and alienated and chased away people like Jonathan and David who could have been a valuable source of support and strength. 

 

Saul’s Legacy

King Saul’s legacy is complex. He is remembered both for his early promise and his tragic downfall. His story serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of disobedience to God, jealousy, and the challenges of leadership. 

Perhaps the greatest tragedy of all is the “what might have been”. Saul possessed qualities that could have helped him to be a good, if not great, king and he squandered it. Worse still, it affected the people who were close to him. Jonathan could have been one of Israel’s greatest kings with his qualities of integrity, fortitude, and loyalty if Saul had managed his life and leadership better. Instead, Jonathan became a casualty on the battlefield alongside his father.    

 

Saul’s Suicide after His Defeat by the Philistines, from ‘The Battles of the Old Testament’, circa 1590–ca. 1610

 

Heartbreaking as it is, and no matter how sorry we feel for him, King Saul’s life is a sobering reminder of the importance of obedience, humility, and reliance on God. It also highlights the dangers of pride, jealousy, and the failure to sincerely repent. His story serves as a valuable lesson in the complexities of leadership and the importance of maintaining a strong moral and spiritual foundation.

 

|Share The Good News|

 

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*